Clue types in a DT crossword

February 15, 2010

An explanation of how the answers are derived in DT Cryptic No. 26164 is available in my blog here:

This is an attempt to classify the clues by their type and analyse the crossword further.

Do leave a comment if you differ in the classification of any clue.

We find that of the 32 clues, the maximum are wordsum (WS) with 8 (I think that in any crossword usually these are bound to be more than any other clue type). Next in descending order: anagram (anag) 6 and double definition, also 6; cryptic definition (CD) 5; container contained (CC) 2; word sum with anagram (WSwAnag), also 2; wordsum with container contained (WSwCC) 1; cryptic and double definition (C&DD), also 1; and antonymic (Ant) also 1.

Abbreviations used:

CD – Cryptic definition
DD – double definition
WS – word sum (also known as charade or combination or as word after word)
Anag – anagram
WSwAnag – Word sum where one component is an anagram
WSwCC – Word sum where one component is a CC
CC – container/contained or word within word (whether one is taken around another or whether is one is inserted in another
C&DD – Cryptic and double definition
Ant – Antonymic (clue-type name that I have just coined: if there is any precedence I shall withdraw this claim

Note: The order of clue types in chart from left to right is the same as from top to bottom in the vertical column alongside

1a Does he take a chance, or just think about it? (10)
9a Peas and carrots are given a star (4)
10a Point to one duke or another (10)
11a Cut by a quarter? That’s serious (6)
12a It could be disastrous when I.O.U runs out (7)
15a Aunt Sal unexpectedly seen in harem (7)
16a Persuade an agency girl to start typing (5)
17a Intervals quietly employed in empty talk (4)
18a Animal quarters, perhaps (4)
19a Jacket cut in style (5)
TUNIC – Anag
21a A place of current conflict (4,3)
22a Bitterness associated with an age old craft (7)
GALL (EON)* -WSwAnag
24a Quick, the doctor’s in the river! (6)
27a Their union offers security (4,3,3)
28a Property to come down (4)
29a Going for acquittal (7,3)

2d Aristocrat always preceded by a page (4)
3d Pillar of the press? (6)
4d It results in a certain jumpiness among rugby players (4-3)
5d Child has a point to convey (4)
6d Becomes exhausted and exits hurriedly (4,3)
7d Davies seen playing a form of Rugby (5-1-4)
8d Manager we’d ordered to run the wild life reserve (4,6)
12d Corner at 90 (5,5)
13d I’m in prison without money, that’s the snag (10)
14d Arrangement not laid down? (3-2)
SET-UP – Antonymic
15d Twig a starting price swindle (5)
19d Interval elapsing before giving sentence to a convict (4,3)
20d Drink in the fresh air next to tents (7)
CAMP (ARI)* – WSwAnag
23d Pet greyhound? (6)
25d Tax which makes a difference to cost (4)
SCOT – Anag
26d Grouse meat (4)


The Times Cryptic 21867

December 3, 2009

Published in the Hindustan Times, Thu., Dec 3, 2009


1 Such an article written in rough (10) INDEFINITE
6 Slight cut to consider (4) THIN(k)
9 As company manager, I am in favour of keeping oriental dress (10) IM PR (E SARI)O
10 Severely criticise the pounds invested in missile (4) S(L)AM
12 Shock as girl gets officer rank (4) JO LT
13 Offensively strike, wanting large sum of money in plant (9) SPEAR MINT
15 Broad smile vanishes, so poorly placed on these? (4-4) BEAM ENDS
16 Finally feed fire in hearth, wood being low (6) D INGLE
18 Get the better of silly person after university (6) O U TWIT
20 Wide-angle shot of original woman with mother, but not daughter (8)PAN(-d)ORA{MA}
23 With case-loads to work through, shelving everything? (9)U NPACKING
24 Sticks back what is cut (4) SNIP<-
26 Bit of news also out of date (4) ITEM
27 OECD members arranged to share medal (10) DECO RATION
28 Frank’s lost house, a pleasant one (4) (ho)NEST
29 Identification of radio station surfers may maximise use of? (10) WAVELENGTH


1 Winger one is putting in book (4) I(B)IS

2 Go down to look at academic’s degree certificate (7) DIP LO MA
3 Pretty girl in Italy might be poor (4,3,5) FEEL THE PINCH
4 In Britain, the left mean to join party (8) NEAR SIDE
5 Time to firmly fix bracket (6) T RIVET

7 Not enjoying touring lake, making slow progress (7) HA(L)TING
8 They made an arrangement to schedule the ceremony (4,3,3) NAME THE DAY*
11 Block ahead of those coming to this false entrance? (8,4) TRAITORS GATE
14 Obtain soul renewal with this? (10) ABSOLUTION*
17 Swamp tree found in island thicket (8) MAN GROVE

19 Slept so badly, half-naked (7) TOPLESS*
21 Established bachelor needs helping out (7) A(B)IDING
22 Screen persons caught up in security organisation (6) CI(N)EMA
25 To an extent, Saharan khamsin made Egyptian cross (4) ANKH (T)

NB: A couple of answers were entered by a couple of members in the  Orkut community: The Hindu Crossword Solutions that I own and moderate.

On Crosaire’s Irish Times Crossword No. 13,901

July 18, 2009

crosaire sat

This is the position after some half-an-hour.

This is my second Crosaire but unlike the other day I have not completed it within allotted time. Some more answers might come after I have laid the crossword aside for some time but I thought I would write this blog in the meanwhile.

I have pleasure in dedicating this post to Bill and the gang at his blog.

As one who has been reading Bill’s blog for the past few days I remembered his recording that the Sat Crosaire has four long peripheral entries with the same string of letters within.

That certainly helped. For Crosaire is a little different from other crossword compilers in that he puts in phrases that are not phrases as we generally understand them and which may not be found in a  dictionary: take THE BOY STOOD ON.  (If you have read the Casabianca poem, you know it. Or else not!  Incidentally, this poem was read to me and my siblings by our Dad when we were children.) So without knowing that useful hint, I might not have got a couple of the long entries today.

As I have said before, Crosaire is an uncoventional setter with a highly personal and individualistic style. You’ve to get used to it before you can complete a crossword of his.



1 MISUNDERSTOOD – Brief and elegant

12 BAIL – usually in crosswords double definition clues are the shortest, probably just two words. Crosaire is expansive even in this clue-type.

17 SAD – this took me a while to get!  The reason is simple, I derive PA, DAD, maybe even OB from Pa. But DA is something new for me. Yet, if I got it, it must be because of reading Bill’s blog. (I suddenly remembered this component from his posts.)

19 YELLOW – simple anagram but the phrase “a shade cowardly” lifts the clue to a higher level.

23 TILLER – I need to check this with Bill’s blog.

25 RANCID – familiar wordplay yet Crosaire gives it the way only he can.

29 OWNS – a deletion clue where the deletion indicator is not too obvious and the surface reading is oh so smooth.

34  OPEN AIR – another anag clue where  the device does not cry out and the surface reading is beautiful.


3 UPON – Wonderful clue.

5 ROUSED – Crosaire has this tendency to use in a crossword something from his previous effort. SKINNY it was the other day. ROUSED it’s today.

14 FANFARE – If this solution was slightly delayed for me, it’s pardonable. With ‘supporter’  I couldn’t get BRA off my mind. (And with ‘something to eat’ I was thinking of  BRAnDISH.)

28 TRYING – Familiar wordplay yet Crosaire gives the clue a new twist by avoiding ‘taxing’ or any other word with the -ing termination.

33 LINO – Excellent clue.

THC (Sun) 2541

July 12, 2009


1 BOTTOM – triple definitions: Weaver (character in Shakespeare’s MND), backside, foot (the lowest point)
5 DOG STAR – Also known as Sirius (which I first came across in Pope’s Rape of the Lock) is the heavenly body, I think. The Lassie part of the clue, I don’t understand.
9 TOTEM – TOTE (carry), M (maiden)
10, 11 HANDLEBAR MOUSTACHE – cryptic definition
12 EMAIL – rev. of Liam (Irishman), E (last in office)
15 DEVIL’S BONES – The latter half of this clue I solved just moments before posting this. Dice are made of bones; Devil’s bones because gambling leads to ruin.
20 AWARD – A (a), WARD (rev. of draw)
24 ALIEN – AN (article) going round LIE ( made-up story)
24 NEST-EGG – anag. of SENT, E.G. (say), G (grand)
26 ALECTO – ALEC (boy), TO(-y) (incomplete toy). Alecto is one of the Furies in Greek mythology.


2 OUTJUMPED – OUT (elsewhere), JUMPED (ran)
3 TEMPT PROVIDENCE – TEMPT (draw) PROVIDENCE (US state capital) :: ‘risk failure’ is the def :: Here, as in 8dn, we take B and add it to A to get AB.
4 MOHICAN – anag. of MACHO IN ( ‘comic’ is the anag. signal)
5 DANSEUR – anag. of US André
6 GOLDEN HANDSHAKE – GOLDEN (successful, prosperous as in the “Golden Age of the Guptas”)), HAND (worker), SHAKE (upset)
7 TIBIA – TIB I [rev. of I BIT (chewed up)], A (a)
8 RARELY – R (resistance), A (a), RELY (bank)
9 TOME – to me (how I may want it dedicated)
16 LACKING – deleting S from SLACKING (skiving, evading duty or work) – the def. for word req’d is ‘missing’ – The deletion fodder occurred to me only now after I had given the crossword a rest.
17 BIRETTA – B (black), anag. of ATTIRE (’ghoulish’ is the anag. signal)
18 PARSON – P(page), ARSON (crime)
19 ANON – (-c)ANON – deleting C(cold) from CANON (clergyman)
21 AMISS – A (a), MISS (young woman)

Comments on THC 9579

July 8, 2009


1 Part of the paper carrying adverts from individuals may, however, pall on consumer (8,6) PERSONAL COLUMN*

***Anag. The def is precise, if lengthy. I have no prob. with the anag. Signal ‘however’. The anag. fodder ‘pall on consumer’ is apposite and gels so well in the surface reading.

8 Good man in demand built a cosy home (6)- NE{ST}ED

***C/c. I feel that ‘demand’ somehow doesn’t go well with the surface reading. Perhaps NEED could have been given gratis, when the surface reading would be perfect.

9 Ancient Italian who subdued centaurs (8) ETRUSCAN*

***Anag. Neat. Acceptable AInd. A neat one-word anag fodder.

11 Burmese Inland Revenue, challenged, will pay back costs incurred (9) REIMBURSE*

***Anag. with an abbr. component. Meaningful surface reading. Again, an acceptable AInd. Some solvers might argue that anag signals must indicate some kind of agitation, shake-up, etc, but I am not among them.

12 Manifold evil revealed in a pithy dramatic work (5) HYDRA

***Hidden. Nice def. Some may say that there’s a word hanging in the hidden fodder but where it improves surface reading I don’t mind it at all. However, here ‘drama’ itself might have been enough.

13 Wild horse in frenzied state, a no-good (7) MUSTANG

***Charade. Must, a N G. The comma is there because the verb is omitted. Clue reads like a newspaper headline.
Surface reading is meaningful.

15 Proteins like pepsin, renin etc (7) ENZYMES


17 Send a rogue to the gallows with this kind of downcast look (7) HANGDOG

***Charade. But this is derived from the phrase “Send a rogue to the gallows” as a whole. As ‘hangdog’ is elliptical from the phrase ‘hangdog look’, the clue has “this kind of”.

19 Gas consumed a newborn child (7) NEONATE

***Charade. Grim event but neat wordplay.

21 Wads of currency needed for a posh car (5) ROLLS

***DD. True statement as well.

23 Sailors swindle the German escaper (9) ABSCONDER

***Charade. Neat, with not a word wasted.

25 Former journalist, accepting fee, is praised (8) EXTOLLED

***C/c. Plausible surface reading.

26 Cheap decoration from cans, Spanish article (6) TINSEL

***Charade. Here the last component is not handled well.

27 What a fiancée may get — a “busy” tone on phone? (10,4) – ENGAGEMENT RING

***DD. DDs are usually pithy but I also like this sort of dual statements.


1 The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog (7) PANGRAM

***Clue by example. I would expect the clue to say this is an instance of what it is.

2 Indian sage of Irish extraction (5) RISHI

***Anag. Neat with good AInd.

3 Where to go if too enthusiastic? Into the water! (9) OVERBOARD

***Interpretative. Raises a smile.

4 Precious stone that makes a gossip audibly suspire (4,3) CAT’S EYE

***Homophone. We have to read the whole phrase “that makes a gossip audibly suspire” to get the ans. What a beautiful word in ‘suspire’. Susurrating!

5 Sound happy (5) – LAUGH

***CD. Pithy!

Evergreen material for road-making I begin applying (9) MACADAMIA

***Charade. Neat surface reading.

7 Odd coins, about 50, in recorded history (6) ANNALS

***C/c. Typo here. ‘Odd’ should have been ‘old’. Should the def have been ‘historical records’ to make it clear that the word req’d is plural. For the def now can give just ‘annal’.

10 Daughter with a worn garment, what a transvestite may wear (4) DRAG

***Charade. An unusual meaning of a known word.

14 Solitary person who made just one century (9) SINGLETON

***Charade. But you have to read the whole phrase “person who made just one century” to get it.

16 He studies animals in Kalamazoo logistically (9) ZOOLOGIST

***Hidden. K. is a place in Michigan (a good discovery) but I feel the word containing the latter part of the word req’d does not go well in the surface reading.

17 Hothead, sporting a gun, caused injury (6) HARMED

***Charade. Perfect English.

18 Good boy, I say, gets an amorous look (4,3) GLAD EYE

***Neat charade with a homophone.

19 Frontal feature, very big in one direction (4) NOSE

***C/c. Good def. I do come across such a thing in someone who is a stranger but whom I come across at an event to which I go from time to time.

20 Individual sound filter (7) EARPLUG

*** Straightforward. Why ‘individual’? Because it is singular whereas the device goes always in a pair.

22 Student in comfortable seat can sing to musical syllables (3-2) SOL-FA

***C/c. Invokes a pleasant image.

24 Old statesman with novel ideas (5)

***Anag. Neat surface reading, ‘old’ and ‘novel’ in contrast with each other.

Adversarial effects of sweet

July 7, 2009

Let’s take the FT clue:
A bit of ecumenical intelligence (6) A CUMEN
Here ‘A’ gives A and ‘bit of ecumenical’ gives CUMEN.
No problem about the clue being charade with a hidden element. The hidden fodder is there (ecumenical), the hidden ind is there (bit of), though there is no def for the hidden component (which is the nonsensical letter string cumen).
Let’s take the other FT clue:
Put some tinsel round the cradle and your name in the book? INS(CRIB)E
Here too in ‘some tinsel’ we have hid ind and hid fodder; INSE goes around CRIB (cradle). There is no def for the hid component (which again is the meaningless letter string INSE) as we generally have in a clue of this type.
Now turning to
Sweet party in call centre DO LCE
I don’t find anything amiss in def and wordplay order.
We have def and then wordplay with a word (DO from party) and then a hidden component.
But there is no ind for the hidden aspect.
I do realise that ‘in’ is not a c/c ind; it may be taken as a connector or a position ind.
Now after DO what do we add in the charade? I feel that with “in call centre” we cannot be expected to pick up LCE, a part of ‘call centre’.
Suppose we rewrite it as
Sweet party for some in the call centre
Sweet party for a section of call centre
Sweet party tucked away in the call centre
In all the three examples it is clear that after DO we have to add some letters picked from ‘call centre’.
‘some in’ or ‘a section of’ or ‘tucked away’ suggests that you have to take part of the following words.
I do not buy the argument that ‘in’ itself suggests that some letters have to be taken from ‘call centre’.
In a regular hidden clue such as
Language of North India (5) HINDI
such an indication may not be necessary though even here purists might argue that the hid ind is weak.
My considered opinion is that the particular clue in the Neyartha crossword somehow fails to achieve the effect that the clue-writer attempted.

TIB 6 – Sol grid

June 17, 2009
Chaturvasi's answers

Chaturvasi's answers